Caley Graber was a three-time girls wrestling state champion and a fifth-place finisher in the boys state tournament for Northfield High School. After winning the girls state title as a freshman in 2023, she finished fifth in the boys tournament as a sophomore in 2024 before returning in 2025 and 2026 to capture girls state titles. Graber had a career record of 41-0 against girls and 100-26 against boys.

She was a freestyle champion at Fargo in 2025 after finishing fifth in 2024, and was also a two-time folkstyle national champion. Graber also competed in the state cross country championships three years.

The daughter of Deb and Jesse Graber, she will continue her wrestling career at McKendree University.